Here are the “big” fish of Lake Ontario listed in order of their IGFA (International Game Fish Association) record weights.
- Lake Sturgeon
IGFA record: 168 lb. 0 oz. Georgian Bay, Ontario, Canada
NYS record: 139 lb. 0 oz. Oneida Lake, Oneida Co. (Protected)
Lake Sturgeon are listed as threatened in New York State and possession of Lake Sturgeon in New York State is prohibited.
- Chinook “King” Salmon
IGFA record: 97 lb. 4 oz. Kenai River, AK, USA
NYS record: 47 lb. 13 oz. Salmon River, Oswego Co.
King Salmon are a native to the North Pacific and were introduced to the Great Lakes in 1967 to aid in controlling an exploding population of the invasive Alewife Herring and aid in a struggling sport fishery. Salmon fishing quickly became a booming eco-tourism opportunity as Sport Fishing the large fish became popular. Today the Great Lakes commercial, recreational, and tribal fisheries are valued at more than $7 Billion and supply nearly 75,000 jobs.
- Atlantic Salmon
IGFA record: 79 lb. 2 oz. Tana River, Norway
NYS record: 24 lb. 14 oz. Lake Ontario, Wayne Co.
Atlantic Salmon are the only Salmon native to the North Atlantic. There is no commercial fishing of wild Atlantic Salmon in the United States. Most commercial Atlantic Salmon is farm raised.
Atlantic Salmon were a staple food of the Native Americans before the first settlers arrived. Commercial fisheries for Atlantic Salmon started in Maine in the 1600s.
- European “Common” Carp
IGFA record: 75 lb. 11 oz. Lac de St. Cassie, France
NYS record: 50 lb. 6 oz. Tomhannock Res, Rensselaer Co.
The European or Eurasian Carp formerly known as the Common Carp is considered an invasive speicies in the United States. The European Carp was intentionally released into North American waters due the Eoropeans affinity for them as a sport fish and as table fare. Du to their intoductions the European Carp is the most widespread freshwater fish in the world and one of the most popular sportfish worldwide.
- Lake Trout
IGFA record: 72 lb. 0 oz. Great Bear Lake, NWT, Canada
NYS record: 41 lb. 8 oz. Lake Erie Chautauqua Co.
Lake trout are actually of the Char family and are found exclusively in the freshwater lakes and rivers of Northern North America. Lake Trout can live for over 25 years, the oldest recorded Lake Trout was 70 years old.
- Muskellunge
IGFA record: 67 lb. 8 oz. Lake Court Oreilles, WI, USA
NYS record: 69 lb. 15 oz. St. Lawrence River, Jefferson Co.
“The Fish of 10,000 Casts” the Muskellunge, aka Musky, is a highly prized sport fish in North America. The Musky is the largest member of the Pike (Esox) Family. The Musky is also the largest exclusiely freshwater sportfish in North America.
- Channel Catfish
IGFA record: 58 lb. 0 oz. Santee Cooper Res., SC, USA
NYS record: 35 lb. 12 oz. Black River, Jefferson Co.
Channel Catfish are the abundant and widespread catfish species in North America. The Channel Catfish is the State Fish of Kansas, Nebraska,Missouri, Iowa, and Tennessee. Channel Catfish contain a venom and causes edema (swelling) and a hemolytic (causeing increased blood flow to the affected area). Smaller Channel Cats are often the most likely to sting as the adult’s spines are dull. Acommon misconception is that the catfish’s barbels are the stingers, this false. The spines are located on the lead edge of the dorsal and pectoral fins.
- Northern Pike
IGFA record: 55 lb. 1 oz. Lake of Grefeern, Germany
NYS record: 46 lb. 2 oz. Great Sacandaga Lake, Fulton Co.
Esox Lucious, the water wolf. The Northern Pike is the smaller cousin the the Musky. Northern Pike are native to North American, England, Ireland, Northern and Eastern Europe. In European countries they called just “Pike” as they are the only Esox genus fish in Europe. Northern Pike is the only esox genus with a circumpolar distribution, meaning that it can found around the entire earths North Pole region.
- Freshwater Drum “Sheepshead”
IGFA record: 54 lb. 8 oz. Nick Jack Lake, TN, USA
NYS record: 36 lb. 0 oz. Oneida Lake, Oneida Co.
The Freshwater Drum can be found in North and Central Americas and is the only member of it’s family that lives exclusively in freshwater. Frashwater drum are the onlyfreshwater fish to lay plantonic eggs meaning that the eggs float towards the surface and are distrubuted by wind and currents.
- Rainbow Trout “Steelhead”
IGFA record: 48 lb. 0 oz. Lake Dienfenbaker, Canada
NYS record: 31 lb. 3 oz. Lake Ontario, Niagra Co.
Steelhead is a name given to ocean run Rainbow Trout. The name is commonly used for Great Lakes Rainbow Trout as once they were oceanic and there are still true steelhead in the Great Lakes and St. Lawerance River.
- Brown Trout
IGFA record: 44 lb. 4 oz. Ohau Canal, Twizel, New Zealand
NYS record: 33 lb. 2 oz. Lake Ontario, Oswego Co.
The Brown Trout is a European Species that was introduced to suitable waters around the world. Brown Trout were first brought to the North American in the 1860s. Brown Trout can be found on every continent with the exception of Antarctca. Brown Trout are also found to be oceanic.
- Longnose Gar
IGFA record: 43 lb. 0 oz. Trinity River, TX, USA
NYS record: 14 lb. 10 oz. Lake Champlain, Washington Co.
This genus has been been present in North America for about 100 Million years. The Longnose Gar contains a vascular air bladder that can act as a simple lung allowing the Longnose Gar to “breathe air” or live in low oxygen environments.
- Coho “Silver” Salmon
IGFA record: 33 lb. 3 oz. Salmon River, Pulaski, NY, USA
NYS record: 33 lb. 7 oz. Lake Ontario, Oswego Co.
Coho Salmon are a native to the North Pacific and were introduced to the Great Lakes in 1966, anglers were excited to see that the salmon made their first spawning run in 1967. Salmon fishing quickly became a booming eco-tourism opportunity as Sport Fishing the large fish became popular. Today the Great Lakes commercial, recreational, and tribal fisheries are valued at more than $7 Billion and supply nearly 75,000 jobs.
- Burbot
IGFA record: 25 lb. 2 oz. Lake Diefenbaker, Saskatchewan, Canada
NYS record: 16 lb. 12 oz. Lake Ontario, Jefferson Co.
Closely related to the Ling-Cod and Cusk the Burbot is the only freshwater member of the family of Cod-like fish. The flesh is highly prized and is often refered to as Poorman’s Lobster.
- Walleye
IGFA record: 25 lb. 0 oz. Old Hickory Lake, TN, USA
NYS record: 18 lb. 2 oz St. Lawrence River, St. Lawrence Co.
The Walleye is the largest member of the Perch Family and is a highly sought after sportfish and table fish.
The Blue Walleye was a color morph found in the Great Lakes and was declared a seperate species in 1926. The Blue Walleye was listed on the endangered species list in 1967 and declared extict in 1983.
- Largemouth Bass
IGFA record: 22 lb. 4 oz. Lake Biwa, Shiga, Japan
NYS record: 11 lb. 4 oz. Buckhorn Lake, Otsego Co.
The Large Mouth Bass is the most populat Freshwater Sportfish in the United States and Japan. Largemouth Bass inhabit every state in the US except Alaska.
The US calculates that 50% of fisherman/women prefer bass fishing which calculates to about 30 million active anglers creating an industry worth $60 Billion.
- Bowfin
IGFA record: 21 lb. 8 oz. Forest Lake, Florence, SC, USA
NYS record: 13 lb. 8 oz. Yanty Creek, Monroe Co.
The Bowfin is another freshwater dinosaur. The Bowfin has inhabited the shallows of North America for 150 milion years. The Bowfin contains a vascular air bladder that can act as a simple lung allowing the Bowfin to “breathe air” or live in low oxygen environments.
Native Bowfin can easily be confused with the invasive Snakehead. Be careful, they are not the same.
- Pink Salmon
IGFA record: 14 lb. 13 oz. Monroe, WA, USA
NYS record: 4 lb. 15 oz. Lake Erie Chautauqua Co.
Unlike Chinnok and Coho Salmon, Pink Salmon were accidentally released into the Great Lakes in 1955. Eggs were being transported from British Columbia to Thunder Bay, Ontario with the idea of raising them in a hatchery and locating them far North of Hudson Bay. After the hatched fingerlings were loaded onto the planes and the planes departed for the workers found about 200,000 fingerlings left behind. Instead of letting the die the workers released them into the Current River, a tributary of Lake Superior.
Pink Salmon are few in numbers and are rarely caught in the Great Lakes.
- Brook Trout
IGFA record: 14 lb. 8 oz. Nipigon River, Ontario, Canada
NYS record: 6 lb. 0 oz. Silver Lake Wilderness Area, Hamilton Co.
Brook Trout are a member of the Char family. Earlier it was stated that Lake Trout were the only member of the Char family that are exclusivly freshwater. That is because there are oceanic Brook Trout in New England that only enter freshwater to spawn. These fish are refered to as “Salters”
- Lake Whitefish
IGFA record: 14 lb. 6 oz. Meaford, Ontario, Canada
NYS record: 10 lb. 8 oz Lake Pleasant, Hamilton Co.
Lake Whitefish is considered on of the best eating freshwater fish there is. They have a high fat content that makes them ideal for smoking.
- Smallmouth Bass
IGFA record: 11 lb. 15 oz. Dale Hollow Lake, TN, USA
NYS record: 8 lb. 4 oz. St. Lawrence River, Jefferson Co.
A new NYS Record of 8 lb. 5.8 oz. was caught in Cayuga Lake on June 16, 2022 but has not been made official as of June 20, 2022.
Smallmouth Bass are a more cold-water fish and inhabit the North and Cental US.
- Chain Pickerel
IGFA record: 9 lb. 6 oz. Homerville, Ga, USA
NYS record: 8 lb. 1 oz. Toronto Res., Sullivan Co.
Chain Pickerel are amoung the most aggressive of all freshwater game fish. The Chain Pickerel inhabits the waters of the East and Gulf coasts.
There are two more species of Pickerel that can be found in the Great Lakes System, the Redfin and Grass Pickerel. Rarely to they excced 15”